More Asset Classes Does Not Equal More Diversification

The Failings of Diversification.

Diversification has been the central tenant of portfolio construction since the early 1950s.

Diversification simply explained, you don’t put all your eggs in one basket.

Nevertheless, technically we want to invest in a combination of lowly correlated asset classes. This will lower portfolio volatility.  (Lowly correlated means returns from assets are largely independent of each other – they have largely different risk and return drivers.)

The article highlights that more asset classes does not equal more diversification.

“This is because the investment returns of a range of asset classes are driven by many of the same factors. These can include: economic growth; valuation; inflation; liquidity; credit; political risk; momentum; manager skill; option premium; and demographic shifts.

So while investors have added a range of asset classes to their portfolio (such as property, infrastructure, distressed debt, and commodities) their portfolio risk remains similar at the expense of adding greater complexity and management cost.”


These are key messages from earlier blogs, focus on true portfolio diversification so as to ride out the volatility and on Liquid Alternative investment strategies.


From the Article

Key Points

  • Diversification is just one risk management tool, not a comprehensive risk management solution.
  • Multiple asset classes won’t lower portfolio risk when the same factors drive each asset classes’ investment returns.
  • Diversification cannot provide protection against systematic risk, such as a global recession, when all major asset classes tend to fall in unison.

Risk comes in many forms but investors are acutely aware of two: the impact of capital losses and extreme bouts of volatility.

Both can have a devastating impact on a portfolio.

Capital losses, such as we saw during the global financial crisis, may never be recouped by some unlucky investors. Meanwhile, volatility can prompt investors to withdraw their money at just the wrong time or quickly erode a lifetime’s savings when an investor is drawing down their capital.

10 thoughts on “More Asset Classes Does Not Equal More Diversification

  1. Pingback: Factor Investing Portfolio Construction | Kiwi Investor Blog

  2. Pingback: Disaggregation of Investment Returns | Kiwi Investor Blog

  3. Pingback: Unintended Portfolio Risks – Fixed Interest example | Kiwi Investor Blog

  4. Pingback: Kiwi Investor Blog achieves 100 not out | Kiwi Investor Blog

  5. Pingback: A short history of Portfolio Diversification | Kiwi Investor Blog

  6. Pingback: Beginners guide to Portfolio Diversification. New Zealand Investors are missing out. And why Portfolios Fail. | Kiwi Investor Blog

  7. Pingback: The opportunity and role of active management | Kiwi Investor Blog

  8. Pingback: Sharemarket crashes – what works best in minimising losses, market timing or diversification? | Kiwi Investor Blog

  9. Pingback: They psychology of Portfolio Diversification | Kiwi Investor Blog

  10. Pingback: Five Myths of About Investment Management Fees – Broadening the Fee Debate | Kiwi Investor Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s